Dermatologists Say These 7 Makeup Habits Can Ruin Your Skin (Here’s What to Do Instead)
Every product on Beauty Empties is one that actually gets used up and bought again. Some of the links in this post are affiliate, which means we may earn a small commission if you make a purchase, at no extra cost to you. Thanks for being here!
The makeup habits dermatologists flag are the small ones that don’t seem like they’re doing damage: the wipes you reach for on tired nights, the mascara that’s been in the makeup bag since last winter, the foundation you put on dry skin at 7 a.m., the brushes nobody is washing. None of these are catastrophic on their own, but a decade of them shows up as the dullness, breakouts, and fine lines you’ve been trying to treat with the rest of your routine.
Most of these come up at almost every dermatology appointment, even when it’s not a makeup question that brought you in. The seven below are the ones that show up most often, with a small fix for each one.
1. Falling asleep in your makeup, even “just this once”
The “just this once” version is the one dermatologists hear most. It’s also the version that does the most damage long term, because nobody counts it as part of the routine. Foundation, sunscreen, sebum (aka oily gunk), and a day’s worth of pollution spend the night marinating against the skin while you’re horizontal and warm. The damage shows up two ways: clogged pores by morning, and a slow inflammation underneath that surfaces months later as dullness, breakouts, and faint pigmentation. The eye area is the most fragile part of the equation; a 2018 medical case report described mascara residue accumulating under a patient’s eyelid after years of skipped removal.
What works instead is a real cleanse, not a wipe (more on those in a second). Dermatologists recommend a double cleanse: an oil-based cleanser first to dissolve the makeup, sunscreen, and the day’s sebum, followed by a gentle gel or cream cleanser to wash off whatever’s left. The oil step is what breaks down silicone-heavy foundation and waterproof mascara in a single pass, which is the difference between waking up with clean skin and waking up with a faint smear on the pillowcase.
DHC Deep Cleansing Oil
The #1 pick for the end-of-day cleanse. The cleansing oil that kicked off the whole double-cleanse trend, on Japanese shelves since 1986 and at Sephora since the early 2000s. The olive-oil base lifts foundation, sunscreen, and waterproof mascara in one pass, then turns into a milky rinse the second water hits it and leaves no film. Reviewers with cystic acne and reviewers with bone-dry skin both report it doesn’t break them out, which is rare in a category that tends to do one or the other.
What Our BEEs Say
BEEs name DHC and Banila Co Clean It Zero as the two cleansers that get finished fastest in this category. The original DHC is what longtime users default to (the green bottle with the olive-oil base, not the newer mild version). One thing comes up across BEE reports: the pump dispenses fast, and a small face needs less than the directions suggest, so most BEEs cut the recommended pump count in half to make the bottle last.
2. Using makeup wipes as your only cleanse
Wipes started as a travel product and turned into a daily one. Most dermatologists will try to talk their patients out of using them every night. The cleansing chemicals in a wipe are designed to be rinsed off after they break down the makeup, but wipes don’t get rinsed. What stays behind is a layer of half-dissolved foundation and detergent residue working into the skin overnight, which shows up as redness, low-grade irritation, and (for a lot of users) breakouts along the jaw and hairline.
A micellar water does what a wipe was supposed to do, without leaving residue on the skin. Micelles (tiny soap-like molecules in water) bind to oil and lift it off when you swipe with a cotton round, and most formulas are designed to be left on without rinsing. The original pink-cap bottle in this category has been a French dermatologist standby for almost thirty years. P.S. We still recommend making this part of a double-cleanse routine!
Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water
The #1 pick for the no-wipe swap. The pink-cap original launched at French pharmacies in 1995 and has been the bottle most board-certified dermatologists hand to a patient with sensitive or breakout-prone skin ever since. The formula is water-based, fragrance-free, and short enough on the ingredient list that you can read it (water, micelles, cucumber extract, and a couple of preservatives). It lifts foundation, lipstick, and most non-waterproof mascara in two swipes, leaves no residue, and doesn’t need rinsing.
What Our BEEs Say
BEEs put Bioderma Sensibio H2O in the same category as drugstore basics that punch above their cost. The pink cap is the original; the blue cap is the formula for oily and combination skin. The shared note is that it lifts most makeup well but isn’t strong enough for waterproof mascara on its own, so a lot of BEEs keep an oil cleanser alongside it for heavy eye-makeup nights.
3. Keeping the same mascara since last winter (and pumping the wand)
Mascara expires faster than anything else in your makeup bag, and almost no one tracks it. The wand goes back into a warm, wet, dark tube every time you use it, which is the perfect environment for bacteria. After about three months, the formula spoils: it dries out, loses its tackiness, and grows enough bacteria that the FDA flags mascara as the highest-risk category in mainstream cosmetics. Most board-certified dermatologists are strict about this one. Three months is the limit, even if there’s still product in the tube.
The pumping part is a separate problem. Every in-and-out pump pushes air into the tube, which speeds up the drying out and moves more bacteria toward the wand. The technique most makeup artists use is to slide the wand out slowly without pumping, and twist it against the inside of the tube on the way up to load it. The other half of the swap is just buying a fresh tube every season, which is easier to commit to when the mascara itself is one you’ll actually finish.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
The #1 pick for the three-month mascara reset. A 2020 launch that turned into a permanent fixture at Target and Walmart and never came off the most-finished list. The flexible bristled wand grabs even short lower lashes without clumping, the formula has fibers for length without flaking by lunch, and the under-$15 price is what makes the seasonal-replacement rule actually easy to follow. Black is the original; Very Black is the saturated version most users default to after the first tube.
What Our BEEs Say
The Sky High formula is the one BEEs default to when they’re starting a fresh three-month replacement clock, mostly because the price makes the rule feel survivable. The wand has fine bristles that reach the lower-lash line without poking the eye. The one shared critique: the formula gets flaky around the three-week mark if you over-pump the wand, which is part of why the no-pump technique earned its way into the BEE community in the first place.
4. Putting foundation on dehydrated skin
Dehydrated skin is the most common reason foundation streaks around the nose and chin within an hour of applying it. When patients blame the formula, dermatologists tend to point to the layer underneath. By 2 p.m. the foundation has settled into every fine line that wasn’t there when you put it on, the texture’s grippy, and the dewy finish you paid for has gone matte and patchy (none of which is the foundation’s fault). All of that disappears once you start moisturizing properly again.
The single biggest difference comes from applying a barrier-supporting moisturizer ten minutes before primer or foundation, on skin that’s still slightly damp from cleanser. The brand matters less than the ingredients: glycerin and hyaluronic acid for the water-binding work, ceramides and squalane for the barrier seal. The most-emptied option in this category is also one of the cheapest, sold in the same French pharmacy bottle since 2009.
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Double Repair Face Moisturizer
The #1 pick for the under-makeup hydration layer. The cream-gel that holds the daily-moisturizer spot for almost every patient who walks out of a French dermatologist’s office. The ingredient list is short and does real work: ceramide-3, niacinamide, glycerin, and the brand’s signature thermal spring water. The texture absorbs in about a minute, doesn’t pill under sunscreen or foundation, and the formula is fragrance-free enough for reactive skin. At roughly $20 for 2.5 ounces, the cost-per-day math is hard to beat.
What Our BEEs Say
In BEE rotation, Toleriane Double Repair holds the same daily-base spot CeraVe AM does (basic, under-makeup, doesn’t pill). The texture is light enough to disappear under primer in two minutes flat, and the ingredient list reads like a dermatology textbook. The recurring critique is the pump bottle, which is hard to use at the very end, so most BEEs end up unscrewing the top to scrape out the last quarter.
5. Not reapplying SPF on a makeup day
Most people remember to put on SPF in the morning, but the reapplication part is where it falls apart. The standard advice (every two hours, more if you’re outside) is basically impossible once you’re wearing a full face of makeup, since cream sunscreen lifts the foundation off and sprays go mostly into the air. Most patients give up and accept that the morning application is the only one they’re getting.
A mineral powder SPF takes care of reapplication. It applies over makeup with a brush, doesn’t disturb the foundation underneath, and adds a real (not theoretical) layer of mineral protection. The pick that comes up most often in derm offices is the one with the Skin Cancer Foundation Seal of Recommendation on the side of the box.
Colorescience Sunforgettable Total Protection Brush-On Shield SPF 50
The #1 pick for reapplying SPF over makeup. The brush is self-dispensing, loaded with mineral powder (titanium dioxide and zinc oxide), broad-spectrum SPF 50, and the Skin Cancer Foundation Seal of Recommendation on the box. The powder applies in fifteen seconds over a full face of makeup, sets the t-zone at the same time, and travels without breaking in a bag. It comes in four tinted shades plus a translucent fair version, none of which leave a white cast on a normal application.
What Our BEEs Say
BEEs use the Colorescience brush as both midday SPF and a powder set, which is why it actually gets finished and refilled. The brush is loaded enough to last roughly four months of daily reapplication. The regular flag is the price (around $69 for the full brush), and the refills take a bit of practice to load without dumping powder onto the counter.
6. Pulling at the eye area to take off eye makeup
The skin around the eye is thinner than the skin anywhere else on the face, and it has fewer of the structural supports (less collagen, less elastin, almost no oil glands) that keep the rest of the face bouncing back. Rubbing and tugging at the eye area to take off mascara is one of the bigger causes of the fine lines and crepiness that show up there later. A bilayer eye-makeup remover (the kind that separates into oil and water in the bottle, then blends back together when you shake it) handles it without any rubbing.
The technique matters as much as the product. A soaked cotton round held against closed lashes for about ten seconds dissolves nearly all eye makeup without movement, and a single downward swipe takes off whatever is left. No back-and-forth, no scrubbing, and no waterproof-mascara fingerprints on the upper cheekbone in the morning.
Clinique Take The Day Off Makeup Remover for Lids, Lashes & Lips
The #1 pick for eye-makeup removal without tugging. The original bilayer formula that separates into a clear oil layer and a tinted water layer in the bottle, then blends into a milky liquid when you shake it. The oil dissolves waterproof mascara, eyeliner, and lipstick in seconds; the water rinses everything off without an oily film on the lashes. Fragrance-free, ophthalmologist-tested, safe for contact-lens wearers, and on Sephora’s most-emptied list since the formula launched.
What Our BEEs Say
Take The Day Off (the bilayer version, not the balm or the cleansing oil from the same line) is the eye remover BEEs name most often when they want the eye area cleared in five seconds without rubbing. The oil layer lifts waterproof mascara; the water layer rinses clean and leaves no film on the lashes. The one thing BEEs flag is the pop-up cap, which has been known to leak in a travel bag (a Ziploc fixes it).
7. Forgetting your makeup brushes exist
A foundation brush picks up foundation, sebum, dead skin cells, and bacteria every time you use it. The bristles hold onto all of it until the next application, when most of it gets pushed back onto your face along with whatever new product is on top. Dermatologists list dirty brushes as one of the easier breakout sources to fix, since it’s basically just a cleaning problem. Once a week is the consensus for face brushes; eye brushes can stretch to every two weeks.
A real brush cleaner is what makes the washing fast enough that it becomes a habit instead of a chore. The pro-grade versions (used backstage on film and television sets, where brushes have to come back clean in under two minutes between takes) dissolve foundation, mascara, and pigment without water and dry the bristles fast enough to use right after. Soap and water still works for a weekly deep clean, and the spray version handles the days in between.
Cinema Secrets Professional Makeup Brush Cleaner
The #1 pick for the weekly brush wash. The cleaner used backstage at film, theater, and broadcast productions where the same brush has to clean and dry in under two minutes between actors. The formula dissolves liquid, cream, and powder makeup on contact, kills surface bacteria, and dries the bristles in about a minute so the brush is usable right after. The 8-ounce bottle lasts roughly a year for a full personal set; the gallon size is what professional makeup artists buy and refill from.
What Our BEEs Say
For weekly brush cleaning to become a habit instead of a Sunday chore, BEEs say the deciding factor is the cleaner. Cinema Secrets is the one that gets named most often, because the formula dries hair brushes and synthetic brushes both within sixty seconds. The trade-off is the smell, which is strong in the way an art-supply store is strong, so most BEEs work near an open window or run the bathroom fan during the deep cleans.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are makeup wipes ever okay to use?
Yes, in the situations they were originally designed for: travel days, planes, anytime you genuinely can’t get to a sink. Treating them as a daily cleanse is where the trouble starts. If you do use one, follow up with a real wash as soon as you can, because the residue left on the skin is what causes the irritation.
How can I tell if my mascara is past its expiration date?
The most reliable signals are the wand (flakes or clumped fibers), the formula (a sharper, more chemical scent than the day you bought it), and the application (it dries down faster than usual). Most mascaras are good for three months from the first use, not from the manufacturing date. Writing the date you opened it on a piece of masking tape stuck to the tube is the trick most makeup artists use to keep track.
Does foundation actually cause acne, or is it the lack of cleansing afterward?
Both, but the bigger issue is what happens at the end of the day. Most modern liquid foundations are non-comedogenic enough to wear safely if the cleanse is thorough. Breakouts blamed on foundation are usually the result of a long day’s worth of foundation, sebum, and pollution sitting against the skin overnight.
Is powder SPF really enough as a reapplication, or do I need cream sunscreen?
Powder SPF works as a reapplication if you’re already wearing sunscreen underneath and you’re using enough of it (two full sweeps across each section of the face every two hours). It isn’t strong enough on its own for a full day outside, but as a top-up over an existing layer, it does the job and (more importantly) it actually gets used.
What’s the right way to wash makeup brushes at home?
Use a gentle clarifying shampoo or a dedicated brush cleaner with lukewarm water (not hot, which warps both the glue and the bristles). Hold the brush bristles-down so water doesn’t run into the metal ferrule and dissolve the glue holding the bristles in place. Squeeze the water out with a clean towel, reshape, and lay flat to dry overnight. A full personal set takes about fifteen minutes once a week.
How often should I actually replace mascara, eyeliner, and liquid foundation?
The general rule is three months for mascara, six months for liquid liner and creamy eyeliner pencils (anywhere the wand or tip goes back into a tube), six months to a year for liquid foundation and concealer in pump bottles, and longer for sharpened pencils because the part you sharpen off acts as its own little reset. The shorter the contact with the skin and the more sealed the container, the longer the product is safe to use.
What Our BEEs Are Buzzing About
Here’s what the beauty community is saying about these habits:
Related Articles
- 5 Makeup Mistakes That Instantly Age You
- 8 Old-School Beauty Products That Are Still the Best Around (Because They Actually Work)
- Skincare Ingredients You Can and Can’t Mix (and the Myths That Aren’t True Anymore)
- The Best Moisturizers for Oily Skin From $15 to $70
- 10 Common Beauty Habits That CAN Work Against Women Over 50
Want to become a Beauty Empties Expert?
BEEs get free products to test, exclusive discount codes from our brand partners, and live access to The Hive sessions with dermatologists and beauty editors. Spots are limited and hand-picked.
Cruelty-free designations on this site reflect each brand’s current Leaping Bunny or PETA certification. Brands without a badge either don’t carry an active certification or sell in markets that require animal testing. Verify directly with the brand if cruelty-free status is a deciding factor for you.
