5 Makeup Mistakes That Instantly Age You (And How to Fix Them)
It happens to all of us. We get used to doing something a certain way and can go years without changing it. That works for some things (the way you take your coffee, where you part your hair). Other beauty habits don’t age as well: 80s blue eyeshadow, 90s thin penciled brows, half a can of Aquanet before leaving the house. Thankfully we were (mostly) forced (humiliated?) away from those.
If you buy through our links, we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Our policy
The harder ones to spot are the habits we haven’t aged out of yet but probably should have. The makeup techniques we picked up in our 20s and 30s tend to be high on the list, and as we get a little, ahem, wiser, they aren’t doing the face any favors anymore. These are the five most common ones, plus the small swaps that work better.
1. Full Coverage Settles Into Every Line
Heavy, thick foundation has had a long run. The lighter alternatives that have mostly taken its place are tinted moisturizers and skin tints (foundations built on a moisturizer or serum base, so the texture is thinner and lighter on skin). They give real coverage but in a sheer-to-medium way that doesn’t sit on top of every line or pore. If your skin has any texture, lines, or pores, heavy foundation tends to settle into them within an hour or two and end up making them look more visible, not less.
The fix: switch to one of those lighter formulas. Look for words like “serum,” “tint,” “glowy,” “radiant,” or “sheer to medium” on the bottle. Apply with damp fingertips or a damp makeup sponge (the most-known one is the Beautyblender), not a thick foundation brush, so the formula melts into skin instead of sitting on top.
L’Oreal Age Perfect Radiant Serum Foundation SPF 50
The drugstore pick. This one is built around a hydrating serum base with SPF 50 baked in. The coverage runs sheer-to-medium and doesn’t settle into lines, with a soft glow finish. It’s around $18 at most drugstores, roughly a third of what most high-end tints cost.
Saie Glowy Super Skin Tint
The clean splurge pick. This is a hydrating serum-foundation hybrid with hyaluronic acid, niacinamide, and licorice root extract for brightness. The finish is dewy without sliding, and the skin still looks like skin underneath. It shows up in beauty editor empties roundups regularly.
2. The Concealer Triangle Works Against You
The under-eye triangle technique is when you draw a long V of concealer from the inner corner of the eye all the way down past the cheekbone, then layer loose powder over the whole thing and let it sit for five minutes (this is called “baking” in makeup, the idea being that body heat sets the makeup in place). It was popularized as a brightening trick. On real skin it tends to do the opposite. The downward V draws the eye to the under-eye area instead of away from it, and the long sit time with that much powder dries out the thinnest, most fragile skin on the face. Concealer creases, settles into every line, and ends up making the under-eye look more tired, not less.
The fix: only conceal where you actually need it. The real shadow under the eye sits near the inner corner, not all the way down to the cheekbone. Tap a small amount of a hydrating concealer into just the inner-corner shadow with a ring finger, blend up and out (not down), and skip the heavy powder layer entirely. If you do want to lock the concealer in place, use a small fluffy brush with a tiny dusting of powder only on the inner corner, and tap most of the powder off the brush first.
NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
The classic editor pick. This is the hydrating concealer that has been a beauty editor standard for years. The texture is creamy without being heavy, and the radiant finish reflects light to brighten the inner-corner shadow without flattening it. The shade range is wide. Pick one shade lighter than your foundation for the inner-corner brightening trick.
Kosas Revealer Super Creamy + Brightening Concealer
The hydrating clean alternative. This is a peptide-rich concealer with a satin finish that genuinely doesn’t crease. It glides over thin under-eye skin without dragging or pulling, and the formula reads as skincare-meets-coverage rather than heavy concealer. On Reddit and in Sephora reviews, the most common compliment is that it stays put through an eight-hour wear without creasing, which is unusual at this coverage level. Certified cruelty-free (Leaping Bunny).
3. Your Blush Is Probably Sitting Too Low
Blush placement matters more than blush color. The old default was applying blush to the apples of the cheeks (the round part that pops out when you smile) and brushing it out toward the temples in a downward direction. That downward direction pulls the eye toward the jaw instead of up toward the cheekbone. Too much color on top of that, and the line you’ve drawn just emphasizes the downward pull instead of lifting the face.
The fix: apply blush ON the apples of your cheeks, then blend UPWARD along the cheekbone toward the temple. The upward direction is the entire trick. It gives the face a subtle visual lift, no contour or highlighter or extra makeup required. Cream blush works better than powder for this, because cream blends into skin without sitting on top and creating a hard edge.
Merit Flush Balm Cream Blush Stick
The buildable stick. This is a sheer cream blush in stick form with vitamin E to help it glide on. Apply directly to the apples of the cheeks and blend with a fingertip. The texture is genuinely beginner-friendly because it’s nearly impossible to over-apply, and the shade range is built for natural-flush effect, not high-pigment color. Certified cruelty-free (Leaping Bunny).
Westman Atelier Baby Cheeks Blush Stick
The editorial cult pick. This is a cream blush from makeup artist Gucci Westman in flattering, slightly-pinched-from-the-cold shades. It’s around $48, but one stick lasts the better part of a year of daily use. The texture is satin-soft and stays put without setting.
4. What Dark Matte Lipstick Does to Your Mouth
Dark matte lipstick (the kind with a flat, no-shine finish) comes with a built-in trade-off. It looks polished in photos and stays put through dinner, which is exactly why every brand was launching one. The cost on lips with any softness or vertical texture is that the dry, flat color settles into every fine line and emphasizes it instead of smoothing over. The lips look smaller than they are, the lines look deeper, and the whole mouth area reads heavier than the actual face.
The fix: switch to a hydrating finish instead of a matte one. Satin (a soft, slightly shiny finish), sheer (a transparent wash of color), or balm-glaze (a balm with a glossy finish) all work. Stick to flattering pink-nudes, warm berries, soft mauves, or dusty roses. Look for formulas with shea butter, hyaluronic acid, or peptides on the ingredient list (those are the moisturizing ones), and skip anything labeled “long-wear matte” for daily wear.
Dior Addict Lip Glow Balm (001 Pink)
The cult satin balm. This is a sheer pink balm that color-adjusts to your natural lip tone, with shea butter and apricot oil for the hydrating finish. The result reads as your lips, just better. The original 001 Pink shade is the universally flattering classic and the most-reviewed of the lineup.
Hourglass Phantom Volumizing Glossy Balm
The plumping satin gloss. It’s a glossy balm with peptides and a non-tacky finish that gives subtle plumping without the burn most lip plumpers cause. On TikTok and in beauty editor empties roundups, the most common compliment is the non-tacky finish. The shade range is built around flattering rose-nudes and soft berries. Certified cruelty-free (PETA).
5. The Case for Way Less Setting Powder
Setting the whole face with translucent powder (loose powder without any color, used to lock makeup in place) used to be the standard. Dewy, glowy, skin-like finishes mostly took over the magazines for a reason. On skin with any texture, an all-over powder does the opposite of what it’s supposed to do. It dries the surface, settles into lines, and creates a flat finish that ends up making the face look older than it actually is.
The fix: use powder only where you actually shine. For most people that’s the T-zone (forehead, nose, chin) and the under-eye where concealer might crease. Skip powder on the cheekbones, jawline, and any area you want to keep looking fresh and glowy. Use a small fluffy brush, tap off most of the powder twice, and apply in a single light pass. Better yet, skip powder entirely most days and use a hydrating setting spray (a fine mist that holds makeup in place without drying the skin out) to lock everything in.
Laura Mercier Translucent Loose Setting Powder
The classic, used sparingly. This is the original makeup-artist standard, and it has been the standard for decades because it works. The trick is using less than you think you need: tap off twice as much powder from the brush, then apply in one light pass to T-zone and under-eye only. One bottle lasts for years if you’re using it correctly.
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray
The no-powder alternative. This is a hydrating setting spray that locks makeup in place without drying or flattening the skin. Spray after foundation, blush, and lip; hold the bottle a foot away; mist twice in a cross pattern. Makeup stays put for hours and the skin still looks like skin.
Three More Worth Flagging
Hard, drawn-on brows. Brows thin naturally over time, especially at the tail end, and the temptation is to draw them back in with a sharp pencil to the shape they used to be. A hard pencil line on a soft brow reads as a drawn-on stripe instead of a real brow. The fix is a tinted brow gel (basically mascara for brows, with color), or a fine-tip pencil applied in short, light strokes that mimic individual hairs.
Heavy contour and bronzer like it’s still 2015. Contour means using a darker matte powder or cream to fake a sculpted shape, usually drawn under the cheekbone, along the temples, and down the sides of the nose. Heavy versions of it were peak Instagram makeup. On a face with any softness, sharp contour reads as heavy and theatrical instead of sculpted. A subtle cream bronzer along the high points of the face (the top of the cheekbones, the bridge of the nose, the jawline, basically the spots that naturally catch light) gives the same brightening effect without the hard edges.
Frosty or chunky shimmer on the lid. Frost shadows (the pearly, icy, slightly metallic eyeshadows) and chunky glitter magnify every bit of texture on the eyelid, and they settle into the natural crease of the lid within an hour. A soft cream shadow in champagne, peach, or rose gold, applied with a fingertip on just the inner third of the lid, gives the eye brightness without the texture problem.
A cruelty-free mark means the brand is certified by PETA, Leaping Bunny, or both at the time of writing. A missing mark doesn’t mean a brand tests on animals; it just means the brand isn’t certified by these programs.
What Our BEEs Are Buzzing About
Here’s the beauty community walking through these techniques in real time:
Want to become a Beauty Empties Expert?
BEEs get free products to test, exclusive discount codes from our brand partners, and live access to The Hive sessions with dermatologists and beauty editors. Spots are limited and hand-picked.
